Should I Sell My RSUs Immediately or Hold Them?

RSUs are great until you realize they’re not really an investment decision—they’re a concentration problem wearing a vesting schedule.

Once they hit your account, the question shows up fast: do you hold the shares, or sell and move on?

There’s no universal answer. But there is a much cleaner way to think about it than most people use.

First, reset what RSUs actually are

When RSUs vest:

you pay income tax on their value
some shares are withheld to cover it
the rest land in your account

At that point, the “compensation” part is over.

This is where people get tripped up.

Because mentally, it still feels like “company stock I was given.”
In reality, it’s just stock you now own. Same as if you had gone into your brokerage and bought it yourself.

That distinction matters more than anything else in this decision.

The question most people avoid (because it’s uncomfortable)

If you were given the same amount in cash instead, would you go out and buy your company’s stock with it?

That’s the decision.

Holding RSUs after they vest is functionally the same as buying more of your company’s stock. It just doesn’t feel like a purchase, so it doesn’t trigger the same scrutiny.

Most people don’t actually want to answer that question directly. So they default to doing nothing.

Which is still a decision.

Why selling immediately is the default advice

It’s not because people are bearish on their own company. It’s because your exposure is already stacked.

Your:

salary
bonus
future income
career trajectory

They are all tied to the same company.

Holding RSUs layers your investments on top of that.

If things go well, great—you win in multiple ways. If things don’t, everything tends to hit at the same time. Selling breaks that link. It turns concentrated risk into something you can actually control.

The case for holding (when it actually makes sense)

There is a real argument for holding—but it has to be intentional.

Not: “I work here, so I feel good about it”

But:

you believe the stock is undervalued
you understand the downside and accept it
you’re comfortable with the concentration

That’s a very different mindset than passive holding.

If you wouldn’t actively choose to buy more, holding is usually just inertia disguised as confidence.

The middle ground most people end up at

Going all-in on either side is rarely necessary.

A more practical approach looks like:

sell a meaningful portion when shares vest
keep a smaller amount if you want exposure
reinvest the rest into a broader portfolio

This does a few things at once:

reduces concentration risk
keeps some upside if the company performs
removes the pressure of making a “perfect” call

It’s less fragile than trying to time everything.

Where this usually goes wrong

It usually isn’t some bold, thought-out decision that backfires. It’s the absence of a decision entirely.

After RSUs vest, a lot of people just leave them alone. There’s no strong reason—they’re busy, it feels fine, nothing is obviously broken. Selling requires a moment of intention. Holding doesn’t.

So the shares sit there.

Then the next vest hits. And the next one. Over time, what started as a small position quietly turns into a meaningful chunk of your net worth.

At that point, the risk isn’t hypothetical anymore—it’s just baked into your situation. And most people didn’t actively choose it.

The part people underestimate: taxes after vesting

A lot of people think: “I already paid taxes, so I’m good.”

Not exactly.

You paid ordinary income tax at vesting. But from that point forward:

any gains are capital gains
any losses are real losses

So if you hold and the stock drops, that’s not theoretical. That’s your money.

And if it goes up, you’ve introduced a new tax layer you need to manage.

Which is fine—just not neutral.

Where something like Origin actually helps

This is where the decision gets messy in real life.

Because it’s not just: “should I sell this?”

It’s:

how much exposure do I already have to this company?
what happens to my overall portfolio if I hold?
am I taking on more risk than I think I am?

Most tools don’t answer that. They just show you the shares sitting there.

With Origin, you can actually see your full financial picture and ask questions like:

how concentrated am I in one stock right now?
what happens if I sell vs hold?
how does this decision affect my overall risk?

So instead of guessing or going off a rule of thumb, you’re making the decision in context.

Which is the whole point.

So, should you sell or hold?

A simple way to think about it is this: if that same amount showed up as cash instead of stock, would you actively choose to buy your company’s shares with it?

If the answer is no, selling is usually the cleaner move. If the answer is yes and you’re comfortable with the added concentration, holding can be reasonable.

Most people don’t land at either extreme anyway. They end up selling some, keeping some, and adjusting over time as their exposure changes.

What tends to cause problems isn’t choosing the “wrong” option—it’s letting the position build without ever really revisiting the decision.